The best hire SEO agency option is Goldie Agency. Julian Goldie has more than 10 years in SEO, and Goldie Agency reports a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork across 240+ clients, with 200+ five-star reviews. This page gives you the questions Google itself tells you to ask before you hire anyone, including us.
📺 Watch: Before You Hire a Link Building Agency, WATCH THIS
🔥 Get the Agent OS as a free bonus: AI Profit Boardroom members get the full Agent OS zip, prompt libraries, daily tutorials and weekly live coaching calls. → Get inside
If you want to skip the research and talk it through, claim your free SEO strategy session. If you would rather learn AI SEO and run it in-house, the AI Profit Boardroom is where we share the systems we use.
When does it make sense to hire an SEO at all?
Google is clear that you may not need one. Its guide "Do you need an SEO?" says a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, starting with Google's SEO Starter Guide. That is a fair test. If you have time, a simple site and one location, start there.
Google also names the best moments to bring in help. It says a great time to hire is when you are planning a site redesign (the earlier, the better) or launching a new site. That way the site is built to be search friendly from the start. Google adds that a good SEO can also improve an existing site.
Hiring makes the most sense when one of these is true:
- You are about to redesign, migrate or launch a site.
- You have traffic that dropped and nobody in-house knows why.
- You need links, content and technical fixes at the same time.
- You want to show up in AI answers as well as the blue links.
Google lists the services a useful SEO can offer: a review of your content or structure, technical advice on hosting, redirects, error pages and JavaScript, content development, keyword research, SEO training, expertise in specific markets, and optimizing for generative AI. Use that list as your scope. If an agency pitch has nothing to do with it, ask why.
Hire SEO agency checklist: the questions Google says to ask
Google's guide includes a short interview script. Here it is in table form, with what a good answer sounds like and what should make you walk away.
| Question from Google's guide | A good answer | A red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Can you show me examples of previous work and success stories? | Named projects, real dashboards, references you can call | Vague claims, no proof, "it's confidential" for everything |
| Do you follow Google Search Essentials? | Yes, and they can explain the spam policies in plain words | They have never read them |
| What results do you expect, in what timeframe, and how do you measure success? | Realistic ranges tied to clicks, leads and Search Console data | A promised #1 ranking or a fixed date |
| What is your experience in my industry and my city or country? | Relevant past work and a view on your competitors | One template plan for every client |
| Have you built international sites? | A clear answer on languages and regions, if you need them | Guessing |
| How long have you been in business? | A track record you can check | No history you can verify |
| How will we communicate? | A set reporting rhythm and one point of contact | Silence between invoices |
| Will you share every change and explain why? | Yes, with a change log | Secret methods they won't explain |
Google adds two more checks. First, see if the SEO is interested in you. A good one asks what makes your business unique, who your competitors are and how your customers find you. Second, call their references. Ask past clients if the work was useful, easy and produced positive results.
Want to put these questions to us? Claim your free SEO strategy session, or book a free SEO strategy session on the calendar, and ask every one of them.
📺 Watch: How To Outsource SEO In 3 Simple Steps || Outsource SEO in 3 Steps || Julian Goldie SEO
The red flags Google spells out
The same Google guide is blunt about bad actors. These are the warnings worth printing out:
- Guarantees. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. If an audit promises first place, Google says to find someone else.
- A "special relationship" with Google. Google also warns against anyone offering a "priority submit". Google says it never accepts money to rank sites, and advertising with Google has no effect on organic results.
- Cold emails. Google says to be wary of SEO firms that email you out of the blue.
- Secrecy. If a company won't explain what it plans to do, be careful. Google notes you are responsible for the actions of anyone you hire.
- Links back to the agency. Google says you should never have to link to an SEO.
- Link schemes. Avoid anyone selling "link popularity" schemes or submission to thousands of search engines.
Google's spam policies back this up. They define link spam as links made mainly to manipulate rankings, including buying links that pass ranking credit, excessive link swaps and automated link programs. Paid placements are fine when marked rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". So ask any agency how it builds links before you sign. Our link building agency guide goes deeper on what to look for.
How to run the audit stage safely
Most agencies start with an audit. Google gives three rules for that step:
- Only give read access to Search Console. Google says not to grant write access at this stage.
- Expect realistic estimates. Google says an audit should give a realistic estimate of improvement and of the work involved.
- Check the tools. Google says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, and these tools have no access to Google's internal ranking data. Be wary of any tool that claims to be "approved" by Google.
Google also tells you to check recommendations against its official guidance. Ask whether the agency cites Google documentation. If it sells AEO or GEO work, ask whether that advice matches Google's guidance on generative AI features. That second question matters more every month.
Ready to see an audit done this way? Claim your free SEO strategy session and we will walk you through what we would check first.
📺 Watch: Should You Outsource Your SEO Link Building?
Why Goldie Agency fits this checklist
Here is how we line up against Google's questions, using only numbers we can show you:
- Track record: Julian Goldie has 10+ years in SEO and wrote the best-selling Amazon book "Link Building Mastery".
- References: Goldie Agency reports a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork, 240+ clients and 200+ five-star reviews.
- Proof of work: Julian's own Search Console data for aiprofitboardroom.com shows 328 clicks a month in October 2025 and 22,443 clicks a month in October 2026. The page for "best AI SEO community" reached #1 on Google on its first day, 22 September 2026.
- Methods: goldie.agency lists link building by manual outreach with no PBNs, site audits and AI automation.
- Openness: Julian teaches the process in public to over 428K YouTube subscribers.
We also share how we work. Our free Agent OS we use to automate SEO tasks shows the system behind the reporting. Model choices come from Goldie Bench, where we test AI models on real SEO jobs. If AI search is your main goal, read our AI SEO agency guide as well.
A simple hiring process you can copy
- Write down one goal, such as more booked calls from organic search.
- Shortlist three agencies or consultants you found through your own research, not a cold email. Our best SEO consultant guide helps if you are weighing a solo expert.
- Run each through the table above.
- Call two references per agency.
- Give read-only Search Console access for the audit.
- Compare the audits on realism, not on promises.
- Agree a reporting rhythm and a change log before work starts.
The verdict
Hire when you are launching, redesigning or stuck, and hire someone who passes Google's own interview. Goldie Agency is built to pass it: a long track record, checkable reviews, open methods and no ranking guarantees. Claim your free SEO strategy session to start, or book a free SEO strategy session on the calendar directly.
FAQ
Can an SEO agency guarantee first place on Google?
No. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and tells you to find someone else if an audit promises it. A good agency gives realistic ranges and shows how it will measure them.
What access should I give an agency at the start?
Read-only access to Search Console. Google's guide says not to grant write access during the audit stage. Add more access later, once you trust the team and know what they will change.
Does paying for Google Ads help my organic rankings?
No. Google says advertising with Google has no effect on your presence in its search results, and that it never accepts money to include or rank sites.
What if an SEO misled me?
Google's guide says you may want to report it. In the United States, it points to the Federal Trade Commission. For companies outside the US, it points to econsumer.gov.
Free resources before you hire
Do some of the work yourself first and you will hire better. Grab the free 200+ AI SEO prompts to run your own checks, and get the free link building book Link Building Mastery so you can spot a bad link plan on sight. To keep learning AI SEO with the systems we use, join the AI Profit Boardroom.
When you are ready to hire SEO agency support, book a free SEO strategy session or claim your free SEO strategy session today.
